I’ve been spending some time on the 1UP.com forums discussing their “what the cell is going on?” article, which compares the graphical achievements of the PS3 (or lack there of) to those of the Xbox 360. The one thing I’ve taken away from talking to PS3 fanboys on those, and other forums is that I’m tired of the “The 360 had a head start… it’s not fair to compare them” arguement. I wrote the following post in the 1up forums to vent, and realized I wanted to put it here for everyone’s enjoyment / hatred, so here goes:
I’m getting veeeerrrry tired of the “the 360’s been out for a year already… it’s not fair to compare them!! Waaaahhhhh!!! ” arguement.
First off, the PS3 was SUPPOSED to be out in March 06….a whopping four months after the 360’s launch…. by that logic, devs should have had the things they needed (dev kits, ect) in hand to work on the games almost as long as 360 devs did….. but they didn’t. Sony fucked up. Production errors and an all around cocky attitude (sony shoots for the sun!) slowed them down. They lost exclusives, and ended up with a half ass launch where they couldn’t even come close to meeting the demand for the console. Hell, they couldn’t even manage a global launch…. MS had shortages, but at least they had them in Europe as well as the US and Japan. Sony and their bungling attempt at a console lauinch are to blame for these comparisons…. if they weren’t shooting for the sun, their launch wouldn’t have burst into flames.
Secondly, How is it unfair to compare a game for the ps3 that I can walk into a store and buy NOW with a game for the 360 that I can walk into the store and buy NOW? The 360 launched a year earlier, and guess what? That’s always going to be true. When the PS3 is celebrating it’s five year anniversarry, the 360 will be celebrating it’s six year anniversary. This will continue to be reflected in the development cycle of games going forward.
It will also continue to be true that the 360 is easier to develop for. So guess what? Even if the PS3 were twice as powerful as the 360 (which it isn’t… they’re on par with one another whether you like it or not) 360 games would probably look as good if not better than PS3 games anyway.
Now, all of that doesn’t mean that the ps3 isn’t a good machine, and it doesn’t even mean that I don’t plan on getting one somewhere down the line, but right now, it’s not worth it.
-MIKE KURZ